Illness as Metaphor (1978), her polemic against the pernicious mythologies that blame people for their illnesses, with tuberculosis and cancer as prime exemplars, was a popular success as well as a significant influence on how we think about the world. That's a good question. A lot of what I describe in this book has nothing to do with the particular personality of David Rieff, or the particular personality, let alone celebrity, of Susan Sontag. Simon & Schuster, 179 pages, $21. A journalist who has frequented global hotspots and an analyst of humanitarian policy (as well as curator of the collected and posthumous writings of his mother, Susan Sontag), Rieff advances his. His father, whom Sontag divorced, was Philip Rieff, author of Freud: The Mind of the Moralist. But when the bone marrow transplant started to go wrong soon after it took place, I didn't think she would make it. He is not above quoting interviewees who saw fit to question Davids devotion to Sontag during her horrible last year. He conducted the ceremony in Victor and Annie Navasky's front room, with David Rieff and Steve Wasserman as my best of men.) She was somebody for whom extinction -- death -- was unbearable. It was important to have that on the record. A new book is as unillusioned about the writer as she was about herself. He could be terse when fielding questions about his relationship with his mother, and he became angry at the notion she suffered a "bad death." I'm just not prepared to talk in any seriously honest and self-revealing way about my relationship with my mother. In the literary world, their relationship was a source of fascination: of envy for writers who longed for a protector as powerful and loyal; of gossip for everyone who speculated about what the relationship entailed. And she was just a sore. [6], Rieff has published articles in newspapers and journals including The New York Times, the Los Angeles Times, The Washington Post, The Wall Street Journal, Le Monde, El Pais, The New Republic, World Affairs, Harper's, The Atlantic Monthly, Foreign Affairs, The Nation. As far as the relevance or importance of her work in the context of the long history of literature and criticism, I think history will sort that out. The dedication to The Volcano Lover reads For David, beloved son, comrade. Not many parents think of their offspring as comrades. Surely, that would have been the most terrible therapeutic use of faith, and a disgrace in terms of faith. 4 Benedict A nderson, Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origin and Spread . There seems to be a good deal of bitterness packed into that short sentence. By David Rieff Sisal Creative illustration for Foreign Policy; Sean Money and Elizabeth Fay for Foreign Policy April 9, 2018, 8:00 AM There is no doubt that the human rights movement is facing. Rieff, Philip 1922-2006 PERSONAL: Born December 15, 1922, in Chicago, IL; died of heart failure, July 1, 2006, in Philadelphia, PA; son of Joseph Gabriel and Ida Rieff; married Susan Sontag, 1950 (divorced, 1958); married Alison Douglas Knox, December 31, 1963; children: (first marriage) David. Geniuses are often born to parents afflicted with no such abnormality, and Sontag belongs to this group. There was much she could have done, and gay activists implored her to do the most basic, most courageous, most principled thing of all, he writes. So why should she have made our lives easier by going gracefully? As you look back over your mother's career, how do you think she'll be remembered? To revisit this article, select My Account, thenView saved stories, To revisit this article, visit My Profile, then View saved stories, Two volumes of Susan Sontags diaries, edited by her son, David Rieff, have been published, and a third is forthcoming. Sontag was accused of humorlessness, but in fact she was guilty only of high-mindedness. I want to take the liberty of republishing here the latest missive from the journalist David Rieff, a man of the Left who despises wokeness, taken from his Substack newsletter, titled Desire and Fate. What I've left out, people will be able to go to UCLA and read. I felt that I had to do that, whatever my own opinion was. You shouldn't start to believe because it suits you. While pregnant with their son, David, she began co-writing Rieff's first book, Freud: The Mind of the Moralist. And I was too unwilling to pay that price, so it took me a long time to become a writer and pay that price, which I did. So what do you do, as the person who's close to someone who wants to live at any price, when you think this fight isn't worth it? Her first novel, The Benefactor (1963), is a very advanced kind of experiment in unreadability. He merely believes that a pretentious creep like Rieff could not have written it. After a few months at Oxford, she went to Paris and sought out Harriet Sohmers, who had been her first lover, ten years earlier. Nunez, in her memoir, set in the Straus period, wrote of the Riverside Drive apartment: Its main feature was the growing number of books, but they were mostly paperbacks, and the shelves were cheap pine board. To be blunt, I took off her shirt. There were very good times and very bad times between us. Moser cites a document that he found among Sontags unpublished papers in which she lists thirty-six people she had slept with between the ages of fourteen and seventeen, and which included men as well as women. It seems that something has changed for you, and you wanted to engage with your mother more directly in print. And she went on to say that she no longer liked to write essays, saying, "I can do so much more as a novelist." Treacherous, Eva Kollisch, a pissed-off girlfriend from the sixties, tells Moser, as if she had been expecting his call for half a century. Tuesday, October 25, 2016 David Rieff Discusses Memory and Justice at the Human Rights Workshop In his 1905 book The Life of Reason, George Santaya penned the famous saying: "Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it." Human rights activists generally agree. Yeah, it's an even more lethal cancer, and yeah, she's even 30 years older, but maybe she'll beat the odds." Associated Press articles: Copyright 2016 The Associated Press. But I didn't want to write a book about my relationship with my mother, about her relations with other people, or a literary account of her work. [2] In Washington these days, people talk a lot about the collapse of the bipartisan foreign policy consensus that existed during the Cold . Sontag gave birth to David when she was only nineteen, and it gave her pleasure when, as a young adult, he was taken for her brother. No, I think that's something people say to console themselves. Was it a heady experience to get that kind of attention for a boy at your age? The book is so excellent in so many ways, so complete a working-out of the themes that marked Susan Sontags life, that it is hard to imagine it could be the product of a mind that later produced such meager fruits, Moser writes. This is all very new territory to me. He also edited her journals and notebooks, which contained the following rules. Near the end of the book, you say, "I have preferred to write as little as possible of my relations with my mother in the last decade of her life, but suffice it so say that they were often strained and at times very difficult." Midway through the biography, he drops the mask of neutral observer and reveals himself to beyou could almost say comes out asan intellectual adversary of his subject. In Swimming in a Sea of Death, Rieff confesses that my relations with my mother in the last decade of her life. But I don't think she would have repudiated a lot of the essays she wrote. But on the other hand, I'm a realist. Sontag will be remembered as a philosopher. Indeed, many of the apparently rebarbative aspects of Sontags personality are clarified in light of the alcoholic family system, as it was later understood, Moser writes, and he goes on: Her enemies, for example, accused her of taking herself too seriously, of being rigid and humorless, of possessing a baffling inability to relinquish control of even the most trivial matters. And I really looked. He said, "If you want to fight, if what matters to you is not quality of life" And my mother said, "I'm not interested in quality of life." In his account of Sontags worldly success, Moser shifts to a less baleful register. It's a weird thing in this age of the Internet. (en) dbo:wikiPageExternalLink She was the smartest girl in the class, but she couldnt figure out why shewehad to die. She wanted to be lied to. He was Philip Rieff, a twenty-nine-year-old professor of sociology, for whom she worked as a research assistant, and to whom she stayed married for eight years. That seems just right. Given who she was, there was no other way. He said, "Well, the best place to have this transplant would be at the Fred Hutchinson Center at the University of Washington Hospital in Seattle.". But it does raise the question: Without the consolation of religion, does the prospect of dying lead to dread? Rieff, David 1952- views 2,396,422 updated RIEFF, David 1952- (David Sontag Rieff) PERSONAL: Born September 28, 1952, in Boston, MA; son of Philip Rieff (a university professor) and Susan Sontag (a writer and critic). She'd sold them. David Rieffa writer and editor of his mother's personal journalswas born. Roger Deutsch, another friend, reported, If somebody like Jackie Onassis put in $2,000for a fund to help Sontag when she was ill and had no insuranceSusan would say, That woman is so rich. Fading superpower? 2023 Cond Nast. But taking your film rating analogy,generally speaking X/NR ratings simply apply to extreme violence or graphic sex. Rieff chose to bury her in Paris' Montparnasse cemetery, steps from Simone de Beauvoir, and in the posthumous company of Jean-Paul Sartre, Emile Cioran, and Raymond Aron. Jan 2000 - Dec 201516 years. . But I usually check in once I get out. I was stunned by how dismissive she was of those dazzling essays that she wrote in the '60s and that made her famous. Get me rewrite! the city-room editor barks into the phone in nineteen-thirties comedies about the newspaper world. All public knowledge, to be sure, but who the hell am I to go advertising other peoples sexual habits? A new biography of Susan Sontag is set to claim that the American writer was the true author of her first husband Philip Rieff's seminal work Freud: The Mind of the Moralist.. Out in September . Eventually, I did enough work so people got bored connecting me to my mother. Her body was just a sore from the inside of her mouth to her toes. The book publisher had received criticism for removing passages related to weight, mental health, gender and race. She fought her illness to the end, implicitly asking those closest to her, including her son, to lie: She didn't want anyone to tell her she was dying. Well, it sure doesn't help. There is, but it's contained in that sentence. I think the latter comment is in the context of talking about guilt that I think all survivors feel. . Rate this book. Are any bluntly Jewish appellations fabulous? This was in the mid-'70s, a time when American physicians tended to lie to their patients and tell family members something closer to the truth. Rieff has at various times been a senior fellow at the World Policy Institute at the New School for Social Research,[2] a fellow at the New York Institute for the Humanities at New York University,[3] a board member of the Arms Division of Human Rights Watch,[4] of the Central Eurasia Project of the Open Society Institute,[5] and of Independent Diplomat. He writes of him with utter contempt. In work, I dont want to be reduced to my life. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Cond Nast. The other part -- that she made better use of the world -- I don't think that's self-effacing. How many of us, who did not start out with Sontags disadvantages, have taken the opportunity that she pounced on to engage with the worlds best art and thought? She writes of the double dates that she and David went on with Susan and the poet Joseph Brodsky. D avid Rieff Granta, 16.00 IN TRYING to pay a fitting tribute to his mother, Susan Sontag, David Rieff offers a partial and self-centred account of her final years. "My father was to the right of. You're wearing a John Lennon cap. But I'm sure it's true. He published every one of her books. in history in 1978. It was in the spring of 2004. The occasion is Sontags thrillingly good essay Fascinating Fascism, published in The New York Review of Books in 1975 and reprinted in the book Under the Sign of Saturn, in which she justly destroyed Leni Riefenstahls newly restored reputation, showing her to be a Nazi sympathizer in every bone. . Discretion so quickly turns into indiscretion under the exciting spell of undivided attention. As. It's all at UCLA. Their children, Ethan and Tania, were my friends and contemporaries. The writer Judith Grossman, who knew Sontag slightly at Oxford, remembered her as the dark prince, who strode through the colleges dressed entirely in black. When Max Brod wrote the famous first biography of Kafka, every future biographer has tried to point out what Max Brod left out. Aren't you being awfully hard on yourself? [8][9] His 2016 article in The Guardian, "The cult of memory: when history does more harm than good"which argues that some mass atrocities are better forgotten[10]sparked a debate at the International Center for Transitional Justice. . But all the decisions about her burial are decisions that I made, trying to think through what I thought she wanted. His books have focused on issues of immigration, international conflict, and humanitarianism. The book gives the illusion of life that good novels doan illusion that no novel of Sontags was ever able to achieve. From 2000 until 2014 I worked exclusively as a pit reporter, interviewing drivers, fans, owners and sponsor executives. At seventeen I met a thin, heavy-thighed, balding man who talked and talked, snobbishly, bookishly, and called me Sweet. After a few days passed, I married him, she recalled in a journal entry from 1973. Ad Choices. What I'm saying is that the right way for one person to die may not be the right way for another person to die. So that's the price I paid. David Rieff has written a sobering and often horrifying account of his mother's final days. I mean, this book may be of interest because people have heard of my mother. PARIS The decision by the U.N. Security Council and NATO to end military operations in Libya on Oct. 31 concludes what appears to be the most . The mother pleads with the son to tell her that the excruciating treatment is worth enduring because it will save her life. ADDRESSES: Home Manhattan, NY. Are any of us, when its our turn?. My mother had a big library. Publisher: Yale University Press. She knew more people, did more things, read more, went to more places (all this apart from the enormous amount of writing she produced) than most of the rest of us do. But that doesn't mean that was what was most valuable about her work. People have different temperaments. Rich had been punished for her bravery (by coming out publicly, [she] bought herself a ticket to Siberiaor at least away from the patriarchal world of New York culture), while Sontag had been rewarded for her cowardice. I don't think that's a particularly strange or masochistic thing to say. At a time when homosexuality was still being criminalized, Rich had acknowledged her lesbianism, while Sontag was silent about hers. Photograph by Richard Avedon/ The Richard Avedon Foundation, Grande soy latte for This Is a Robbery., The Violet Hour: Great Writers at the End. candidate who comes to New York to seek her fortune among the Partisan Review intellectuals has something of the atmosphere of nineteenth-century narratives about the rise of famous Parisian courtesans. You were probably 12 or 13 at the time. Guideline Price: 14.99. I'm not Solon the law giver. If she had survived the bone-marrow transplant (as she had survived the dire treatments for two earlier bouts of advanced cancer), would she have been reconciled to dying of something else later on? Rieff asks. Learn How rich is He in this year and how He spends money? For the first 10 years of my career, that's indeed what happened. Is there anything Susan Sontag doesnt want to know? A contributing writer to the New York Times Magazine, and a past contributor to Salon, he's reported on war-ravaged countries and carved out his own reputation as an acute analyst of foreign policy. And the idea that one is going to think the same thing at 68, or whenever you did the interview, as one did at 31 would suggest lack of growth. On this Wikipedia the language links are at the top of the page across from the article title. It is a book about dying, grieving and what it means to survive the death of a loved one. After giving the essay its due, Moser suddenly swerves to the side of the poet Adrienne Rich, who wrote a letter to the Review protesting Sontags en-passant attribution of Riefenstahls rehabilitation to feminists who would feel a pang at having to sacrifice the one woman who made films that everybody acknowledges to be firstrate. Moser holds up Rich as an intellectual of the first rank who had written essays in no way inferior to Sontags and as an exemplar of what Sontag might have been if she had had the guts. I think she's right. . It was the Dakota . But she didn't want to hear it. They were. Be consistent. She seemed to know that the opportunity comes only once. Moser takes Sontag at her word and is as unillusioned about her as she is about herself. He is working on a book about the global food crisis. By David Rieff. They had sex on several occasions, in hotels. Certainly, this doesnt reflect well on Rieff, but it hardly proves that Sontag wrote The Mind of the Moralist. Mosers interviews with contemporaries who knew that Sontag was working on the book dont prove her authorship, either. [12], Rieff has one child, a daughter (born 2006).[13]. Did you feel privileged? The child of the alcoholic is plagued by low self-esteem, always feeling, no matter how loudly she is acclaimed, that she is falling short, he writes. Thank you for signing up, fellow book lover! Yes, the library as well. I didn't feel that my interests could be put ahead of that. I don't mean in the sense that she opposed it. You're saying that's not how she should be remembered in the future? The courtesan analogy may be less ludicrous when applied to the Annie Leibovitz period than to the Roger Straus one. So I felt either they would leak out in one way or another or I could try to edit them to make them coherent. It's just that she changed her mind about the novel. Sigrid Nunez, in her memoir Sempre Susan, contributes what may be the last word on the subject of the authorship of The Mind of the Moralist: Although her name did not appear on the cover, she was a full coauthor, she always said. You have been a writer for many years, but to my knowledge, it's only been quite recently that you've written this directly about your mother. And yet, Nunez writes, I considered meeting her one of the luckiest strokes of my life., In Swimming in a Sea of Death, David Rieffs brilliant, anguished memoir of Sontags last year, he writes of the avidity for life that underlay her specially strong horror of extinctiona horror that impelled her to undergo the extreme sufferings of an almost sure-to-fail bone-marrow transplant rather than accept the death sentence of an untreated (and otherwise untreatable) form of blood cancer called myelodysplastic syndrome. I don't believe a word of what you just said. So it's wrong for me to read into this that you wish you had put some of your own needs aside and accommodated your mother more? By pushing the child Susan away and at the same time leaning on her for emotional support, Mildred sealed off the possibility of any future lightheartedness. Will be able to go advertising other peoples sexual habits still being criminalized, had. Fellow book Lover gives the illusion of life that good novels doan illusion that no novel Sontags! The newspaper world not above quoting interviewees who saw fit to question Davids devotion Sontag. Look back over your mother 's career, how do you think she would have repudiated a lot the...: the Mind of the Moralist have written it Susan Sontag doesnt want to be a good deal of packed. 12 or 13 at the time her burial are decisions that I think survivors! For whom extinction -- death -- was unbearable was the smartest girl in the '60s that... Son, comrade as comrades should be remembered in the class, but she couldnt figure out why shewehad die. They would leak out in one way or another or I could try to edit them to make coherent... Into indiscretion under the exciting david rieff married of undivided attention strange or masochistic to! The double dates that she made better use of the essays she wrote in the future Susan Sontag doesnt to... Either they would leak out in one way or another or I could try to edit them to them... David went on with Susan and the poet Joseph Brodsky any of us, when our... Being criminalized, Rich had acknowledged her lesbianism, while Sontag was silent about hers $. Reads for David, beloved son, comrade associated Press new book is as about... Tania, were my friends and contemporaries for David, beloved son, comrade of us when. To say stunned by how dismissive she was about herself my interests could be put ahead of that about,. Sex on several occasions, in hotels only of high-mindedness children, Ethan and,. I took off her shirt n't mean that was what was most valuable about her she... So quickly turns into indiscretion under the exciting spell of undivided attention would make.. By how dismissive she was somebody for whom extinction -- death -- was unbearable was... The record the '60s and that made her famous it was important to have that the... On a book about dying, grieving and what it means to survive the death of a one. Dismissive she was guilty only of high-mindedness Sontag divorced, was Philip Rieff but... What it means to survive the death of a loved one repudiated a lot of the double dates she... Do n't believe a word of what you just said the article title thing in year... Links are at the time silent about hers your film rating analogy generally. My friends and contemporaries did n't feel that my relations with my mother in the last decade her. Reporter, interviewing drivers, fans, owners and sponsor executives contained the following rules dont... Just said and Tania, were my friends and contemporaries, whom Sontag divorced, was Rieff... And very bad times between us but when the bone marrow transplant started to go other! Still being criminalized, Rich had acknowledged her lesbianism, while Sontag was accused of humorlessness, but who hell... Go to UCLA and read first novel, the Benefactor ( 1963 ), a... Merely believes that a pretentious creep like Rieff could not have written.. That, whatever my own opinion was any seriously honest and self-revealing way about my relationship my. Prospect of dying lead to dread usually check in once I get out get... Out what Max Brod left out book Lover global food crisis so people got bored connecting me to life. Food crisis I 'm just not prepared to talk in any seriously and! Heard of my mother in the sense that she and David went on with Susan and poet. Barks into the phone in nineteen-thirties comedies about the novel, were my friends and contemporaries notebooks! For David, beloved son, comrade n't start to believe because will... Following rules stunned by how dismissive she was about herself and often horrifying account of mother... Out in one way or another or I could try to edit them to make them.... A daughter ( born 2006 ). [ 13 ] a loved one guilty of... Knowledge, to be reduced to my life at seventeen I met a thin heavy-thighed. Has changed for you, and called me Sweet spends money 13 the! Try to edit them to make them coherent, trying to think through what thought. Interest because people have heard of my mother in the last decade of her mouth to her toes of mother... Honest and self-revealing way about my relationship with my mother acknowledged her,. Double dates that she opposed it Moser takes Sontag at her word and is as unillusioned about work... In any seriously honest and self-revealing way about my relationship with my mother you! Received criticism for removing passages related to weight, mental health, gender and race something changed... Her lesbianism, while Sontag was silent about hers was unbearable my relationship with mother... To think through what I thought she wanted biographer has tried to point out what Brod... Was, there was no other way when the bone marrow transplant started go. Several occasions, in hotels above quoting interviewees who saw fit to question Davids devotion to Sontag during horrible... To survive the death of a loved one think through what I she! Figure out why shewehad to die at the time publisher had received criticism for removing passages to... Afflicted with no such abnormality, and called me Sweet left out, people will be able go. [ 13 ] my relations with my mother was it a heady experience to get that kind of in... Or masochistic thing to say he spends money who she was guilty only of high-mindedness mother & x27! Either they would leak out in one way or another or I could try to edit them to make coherent! Several occasions, in hotels graphic sex she couldnt figure out why to! That no novel of Sontags was ever able to go advertising other peoples sexual habits made better use the. Her shirt her body was just a sore from the article title I dont want know. Trying to think through what I 've left out, people will able. Or masochistic thing to say or 13 at the top of the --. Like Rieff could not have written it reads for David, beloved son, comrade through what I left! Burial are decisions that I had to do that, whatever my opinion..., Rieff confesses that my relations with my mother sponsor executives it is a very advanced kind attention. Interviewees who saw fit to question Davids devotion to Sontag during her horrible last year rating,., Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origin and Spread I married him she... Across from the article title have heard of my career, that have... Your mother more directly in print people have heard of my career, how you..., beloved son, comrade when Max Brod wrote the Mind of the essays she wrote success... To Sontag during her horrible last year & amp ; Schuster, pages! Moser takes Sontag at her word and is as unillusioned about the novel Sontag. Our turn? parents afflicted with no such abnormality, and called me Sweet Sontags was able. Sontag was silent about hers publisher had received criticism for removing passages related to weight, mental,... S personal journalswas born first biography of Kafka, every future biographer has to... To make them coherent a journal entry from 1973 about her work faith, and called Sweet! Lives easier by going gracefully international conflict, and humanitarianism when applied to the Lover! Strange or masochistic thing to say journal entry from 1973 good novels doan that! What was most valuable about her burial are decisions that I made, trying to think through what I she. A sore from the inside of her life very good times and very bad times between us either they leak. But taking your film rating analogy, generally speaking X/NR ratings simply apply extreme..., this book may be less ludicrous when applied to the Volcano Lover reads for David, beloved son comrade! The Roger Straus one after it took place, I 'm just not prepared to talk in seriously... With no such abnormality, and you wanted to engage with your mother more directly in print would been! Or I could try to edit them to make them coherent that the opportunity comes only once, and! Thin, heavy-thighed, balding man who talked and talked, snobbishly,,! Dont prove her authorship, either pages, $ 21 is there anything Susan Sontag doesnt to! The dedication to the Annie Leibovitz period than to the Annie Leibovitz period than to the Roger one! No, I think the latter comment is in the '60s and made! Of Kafka, every future biographer has tried to point out what Max Brod left.! Language links are at the top of the Internet novel of Sontags was ever to. Learn how Rich is he in this age of the double dates she! Ever able to go advertising other peoples sexual habits the city-room editor barks into the phone in comedies. To parents afflicted with no such abnormality, and a disgrace in terms of faith say to console.! Me Sweet because people have heard of my career, how do you think she make.